While he works this post has grown a little long, so here's an overview.
There are a lot of quotes, mostly from Ramaswami's newsletter this month on Mudras, I highly recommend reading the whole thing
Basically I pick up on a question raised in a post comment about mention of Mudra in Nancy Gilgoff' 1974 Ashtanga syllabus and ask what happened to mudras in Ashtanga, why so little mention of them.
With the help of Ramaswami I look at what Mudras are and find them buried away within Ashtanga but then suggest that mudras are gestures, that there is an involvement, an attitude, an engagement, without which they are merely shapes.
I focus on Mudra as seals
As an intense focus of concentration.
After looking at some of the Mudras Krishnamacharya advised against, again with Ramaswami's help, I look at Mudra's as concentration, a support for pranayama this time with the help of a lecture by Krishnamacharya's son Sri TK Sribhashyam.
The second half of the post looks at some common important mudras as well as full body mudras many of which are familiar to Ashtanga
I received a comment on Ramaswami's Newsletter post this week
look kpjois plan of study in second year includes up mudras mudras hand gestures dasha mudras
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Er86YgP1Po
Single hand mudras
Mudras with both hands
There's a charming ( and slightly risqué), scene in the Ang Lee's film Life of Pi, ( from the Yann Martel's novel) released over the holidays, where the hero, Pi, playing a drum in a dance school, demonstrates some mudra's he's seen but asks the dancer he's fallen in love with about a particular mudra he doesn't understand.
Here's Ramaswami again on some of the different Mudras found in Hatha yoga texts
So there are still mudras in Pattabhi Jois' Ashtanga ?
The three main Bandhas, Moola, Udiyana and Jalandhra might be considered mudras, particularly when employed together. Mula and uddiyana at least, are practiced throughout Ashtanga, Jalendhara less so but we still find it along with the other two in the likes of, baddha konasana and baddha padmasana.
The inversions, sirsasana (headstand) and sarvangasana ( shoulder stand) can be considered mudras and these are included during every practice in the finishing sequence.
But surely, moola and udiyana bandha are encouraged in Primary series as are shoulderstand and headstand. Why then does Pattabhi Jois leave it until the third year of the Nancy Gilgoff 1974 Syllabus to mention mudras and place them along with kriyas with the Advanced A postures, 3rd series?
Mudra is more than posture, whether employing full body or just the hands, Mudra as gesture is an approach, an attitude, an engagement.
But then, in this sense perhaps, for B.K.S.Iyengar and Pranshant Iyengar in particular, all asana could ultimately be practiced or at least explored as gesture, as prayer.
And don't we like to think of our most solid Ashtanga practice as fully engaged.
The important point to keep in mind though, what distinguishes mudra practiced as mudra seems to be that...
They are highly focussed, we dwell in them, engaging bandhas, directing prana.
In Yoga Makaranda Krishnamacharya, slows the breath, engages the bandhas, often employing Kumbhaka, he encourages long stays, is he approaching asana as mudra?
Almost perhaps but not quite, not all postures it seems work as mudras, there is that locking, sealing aspect, see the examples at the bottom of the page. Some postures it seems are more suited than others for this work.
I still struggle with the nadis model, the movement of prana, I employ it somewhat under erasure.
Krishnamacharya's son, Sri TK Sribhashyam, talks of mudra as a posture for highly focussed concentration, I find this a good working model.
"The Mudra represent some postures in yoga which include a concentration or a specific point within the body or outside the body"
"Pearl" or the influence of Mudra and Prânâyâma in a spiritual search
Seminar given by Sri TK Sribhashyam in Neuchâtel from 29.07 to 08.01.06
Ramaswami taught maha mudra to us as part of the Asymmetric sequence, however, practiced as a mudra one would stay for a longer period of time than perhaps we might wish in a particular sequence during our asana practice, we might perhaps choose to practice Janu sirsasana in it's place.
So a mudra can be practiced as an asana as well as mudra. We tend to practice Sirsasana as asana, but rarely, if at all, as mudra.
Why is that?
Ramaswami would suggest we practice maha mudra at the end of our asana practice, perhaps before pranayama when we might stay for five minutes each side, engaging moola, full uddiyana and full jalandhara bandha as well as including kumbhaka ( breath retention) on our long slow inhalations and exhalations.
Here I have to bring up something uncomfortable for me personally, this from page 50 of Krishnamacharya's Yoga Makaranda.
Krishnamacharya Yoga Makaranda p50
Before practising Pranayama?????
All twenty?
Even the weird one?
"But Sri Krishnamacharya had some strong reservations about some of the
mudras, so do several orthodox Indians. He would say, inter alia, that
there are several practices under the name of yoga and it becomes
important to pick and choose those practices that are wholesome and
reject others that could be harmful to the unsuspecting yogabhyasi. So
his advise would be to stick to Patanjali's yoga as the bible of yoga
and anything that goes against the tenets should be eschewed in one's
practice.
What were the practices, especially mudras, my Acharya was not in
favour of? Mudras like the famous Kechari mudra, Yoni Mudra as
described in HYP, Vajroli Amaroli and similar practices. Why so?
Because these practices were not conducive to the satvic goal of
Kaivalya which Raja Yoga is meant to take the abhyasi to. But then
hatayoga is meant to be a stepping stone for Rajayoga. Yes but then
the Rajayogi will have to see if any of the procedures of hatayoga
violate any rajayoga rules and these mudras mentioned are considered
to violate that. Even as hatayogis claim that these procedures help
one to maintain Brahmacharya under the most provocative circumstances
they are unnecessary risks and many yogabhyasis fail miserably, like
even the great sage Viswamitra. And they have no bearing whatsoever on
the ultimate goal of Kaivalya which the orthodox Rajayogi is after and
they directly violate the yama niyamas like saucha and brahmacharya.
If they violate these aspects of yamaniyamas don't hatayogis believe
in these tenets? Further Sri Krsihnamacharya has himself mentioned and
described some of the mudras like kechari mudra, vajroli mudra in his
Yogamakaranda.. But if you carefully read his Yoga Makaranda the
rather embarrassing benefits mentioned with Kechari mudra in
Hatayogapradipika are not referred to by TK. Further his Vajroli mudra
as per Rajayoga is very different from what you find HYP, and his own
alternative description of Vajroli mudra following the hatayoga
school is more a therapeutic tool and not as described in HYP. He
also mentioned during my classes that the somewhat surgical procedure
mentioned HYP ( as also in Yoga Makaranda) of kechari mudra is a
risky procedure and he would suggest use of Jihwa bandha instead
rather than the more extreme Kechari mudra using a knife. I think
Krishnamacharya's teaching should be understood not merely by reading
his books but by following what he really taught to his students. In a
book one has to present the subject in its totality but while teaching
he would teach what is acceptable and what is not".
Srivatsa Ramaswami January 2013 Vinyasa Krama newsletter
So although Krishnamacharya listed twenty mudras in his Yoga Makaranda he did not encourage the practice of many of them. So no, we don't need to master all twenty mudra's before we begin our practice of pranayama, phew.
In fact pranayama may be considered a prerequisite for fully engaged practice of mudra
"Yogis, especially hatayogis, do a set of unique procedures called
mudras, the prerequisites of which are asanas and pranayama. In this,
one could see that the yogi is able to access several of the internal
organs, the kosas and other supporting organs inside the body. But
more than that there is an esoteric purpose. By Pranayama the Hatayogi
is able to cleanse the various nadis and draw in the dispersed prana,
enabling the union of prana and apana. Now the yogi would like to
further elevate the united prana through the Sushumna and achieve the
goal of Hatayoga which is known by various names such as unmani
avasta and others. Towards that the prana withdrawn from the various
nadis should be prevented from going outward and this is supposed to
be achieved by blocking the various nadi pathways by sealing them
through the procedures called mudras like the check valve used by
plumbers. Mudras thus help to seal some of the nadis, arouse the
Kundalini, open up the chakras and thus pave the way for the upward
movement of the Prana through the Sushumna. The mudras also create the
condition for the Yogi to achieve the unmani avasta or immense joyful
state within oneself. Without the distractions of the sensations like
the visual, tactile and other sensations the Hatayogi is able to
achieve immense joy".
Srivatsa Ramaswami January 2013 Vinyasa Krama newsletter
Krishnamacharya's son, Sri TK Sribhashyam, considers mudra to be a support for pranayama a practice to develop concentration and one pointedness.
"Yoga has two elements to support our spirituality breathing Prânâyâma, and include breathing postures and concentration, called Mudra".
Mudra
Mudra practice helps us offset the influence emotional during concentration. The Mudra represent some postures in yoga which include a concentration or a specific point within the body or outside the body. External objects are divine objects, which are devoid of human emotions. In Yoga we do not use objects that have a dependency with our emotions and human relations.
The outer points are points of connection between the soul and the Creator.
Points inside the body are like a network and relate to the existence of the soul in life. These very specific points of concentration are considered divine objects.
Concentration is added to the number of breaths specific (3, 6 or 12). The Mudra can be practiced alone, in no specific order, because their role is on an emotional level, it involves cutting the interrelationship between sense perception and emotions.
Here are some points of focus:
- Adityas (Sun): it is the solar disk, black and shiny, which is the door to go beyond this world. This concentration is against the practice.
- The Star: lying on the back, direct the eye as far as possible in the sky.
- Taraka: it is the point on the horizon, infinity beyond the earthly world.
- Murdhna: this is a point which lies to the root of the nose. Murdhna gives us the support of spiritual masters. It is thanks to their light, their spiritual strength as we continue to move towards the Creator. It is our belief that nourish them and help us to strengthen it.
- Divya Chakshush: point of the occiput. Divya Chakshush means "vision of God" is one of the largest concentrations for the vision of our soul.
- Nasaagra: tip of the nose. Reduced from dispersions of sense perception.
- Nabhi: behind the navel. Nabhi restores harmony in the emotional activity.
- Mula: Mula means "root", it is located between the anus and the genitals. This is an extremely important point. This is to bring all of our different human emotions to the root of emotions, Mula, to activate and give way to the divine emotion.
- Bruhmadhya: the point between the eyebrows. In philosophical terms, its meaning is "land between the two" heavenly and earthly.
- Shirsha: fontanelle. It is located in the upper part of the skull at the inside. It is also a vital point, since the soul is supposed to leave at death. The soul is often seen as confined to Mula. It is therefore necessary to create a path for him to go Shirsha, concentration upward, directing the gaze Mula and follow a vertical line Shirsha.
- Hrudaya: the place of residence of God in us. It is a little outside the physiological heart. In the concentration of Mula Shirsha to it automatically by Hrudaya. This is protected from any human emotion. As a state mental Hrudaya is given automatically when the field is free of mental sensations and emotions.
"Pearl" or the influence of Mudra and Prânâyâma in a spiritual search
Seminar given by Sri TK Sribhashyam in Neuchâtel from 29.07 to 08.01.06
What then are the more important mudras that we should perhaps be practising?
Here's one that Patanjali seems to recommend
Shanmukhi mudra
"Does Patanjali recommend Mudras? He seems to recommend one Mudra for sure
which is the graceful and charming Shanmukhi mudra. It is symbolic
hand mudra and also seals the indriyas perfectly meeting the
definition of pratyahara. It is both a seal and joyful procedure".
Srivatsa Ramaswami January 2013 Vinyasa Krama newsletter
I went so far as to use it for the cover of my practice book
LINK |
from the top of my blog |
Swami Satyananda Saraswati's in his book Asana Pranayama Mudra Bandha, has this to say in his section on Mudras.
Maha Mudra
In Ashtanga, I include Maha Mudra before Janu Sirsana A. I engage all the bandhas strongly and stay for ten breaths each side. It refocuses my attention on the breath and bandhas and I finding somehow grounding.
Another favourite is Mahabandhasana (the great lock). I slip this into Intermediate after Bakasana and before Bharadavajrasana (which is pretty much a twisted version of the mudra). If you don't like Maha Mudra so much you could use this after Tirang Mukkha Eka pada Paschimottanasana. From that posture I tend to cross my extended leg into half lotus to jump back anyway, which pretty much puts me into the mudra. Similarly, following Krounchasana in 2nd series or perhaps after Supta Urdhva Pada Vajrasana, it'll settle you before the seven deadlies.
Vinyasa Krama recommends taking mini Savasanas to settle the breath and heartrate. Breath should be steady in Ashtanga too. Rather than just taking a Savasana you can bring in Tatkamudra (the pond gesture the belly in full Uddiyana looks like a pond). I like it after Supta Vajrasana or Karandavasana, again it slows me down, grounds me, reminds me what I'm doing there on the mat. I also like it towards the end of the practice before the Shoulder stands