I was asked about my practice now I'm here in rural Japan between the mountains and Lake Biwa.
While my Mac is out of action and in need of a new Hard drive I thought I'd repost this outline from last year of the Slow Ashtanga I'm pretty much practicing here.
Difference from below? I tend to start with a simple pranayama, something from Sri Sribashyam's (Krishanmacharya's third son) Emergence of yoga say, then a little tadasana ( Vinyasa Krama) and a rough sketch of Ashtanga Primary or the first half of Ashtanga 2nd. There tends to be a strong Vinyasa Krama influence, the odd variation included perhaps in preparation or as an extension. My breathing tends to be long and slow following Krishnamacharya's early writing, Kumbhaka too of course and I7ve been including internal drishti from some time along the the lines of Sri Sribasham's teaching. Practising slow like this I choose to practice less asana to leave more time for pranayama ( mostly nadi sodhana with mantra - see my pranayama page above), pratyahara and an appropriate Sit.
I should add perhaps that asana attainment has lost all interest for me, gone the leg behind head postures, karandavasana, even supta Kurmasana and Marichi D (perhaps in summer), kapo tends to be toes at best when I remember to include it. I'm currently more interested in the longer, slower, steady breathing, the kumbhaka said and the internal drishti, mostly though I'm leaning more towards my simple, straight forward pranayama and peace in my sit.
It is so beautiful here.
The new practice space, the view and what's left of the yoga book shelf after the move to Japan.
Original post below from 8th November 2014
This post is an attempt to answer the question above with this morning's practice as an example but bringing in some of my older videos relating to slower practice I. E. slower breathing, longer stays (rishi approach) kumbhaka, adapting the 'sequence' to the demands of a slower practice etc. It's along the lines of the kind of practice I've been teaching in crete this summer and will be looking to present, at some point, in my upcoming workshops (see right panel of blog).
I thought I'd put this up at the top of the blog as a permanent page and develop it over time..
I think of the indications below more as options for practice that Krishnamacharya emphasised in his early Mysore writings (1930s-40s), back when he was still teaching the young Pattabhi Jois.
Slow Ashtanga
- Longer, slower breathing
- Longer stays in some asana, shorter stays in others
- Kumbhaka ( retaining the breath in for between 2 and 10 seconds after the inhalation and/or retaining the breath out for between 2 and 10 seconds after the exhalation) dependent on the particular asana or mudra.
- It may well follow the general framework of the current Ashtanga sequence but the sequence split perhaps over two or more days.
- Due to splitting up the sequence other asana or variations of asana may be included to prepare or extend a key asana in the days practice
"When once a fair proficiency has been attained in asana and pranayama, the aspirant to dhyana has to regulate the time to be spent on each and choose the particular asanas and pranayama which will have the most effect in strengthening the higher organs and centres of perception and thus aid him in attaining dhyana". Krishnamacharya - Dhyana or meditation Yoga Makaranda part II
Sample practice from this morning Approx. 2 hours
The videos may take some time to load, don't worry, your unlikely to watch them anyway, it's like watching dry or grass grow.
Numbers beside the postures indicate no. of breaths unless 'times' or 'cycles' indicated
AK = antar kumbhaka (retaining the breath in at the end of the inhalation )
BK = bhaya Kumbhaka (holding the breath out at the end of the exhalation)
Krishnamacharya doesn't say how long the kumbhaka's should be Yoga Makaranda in Part I but in Part II they tend to be working up from 2-5 seconds in later krishnamacharya with experience they may be 10 seconds. those indicated below are my own kumbhakas.
Ujjayi in tatkamudra - 6 breaths ( scanning vital points on inhalation, nabhi on exhalation)
Anuloma ujjai - in Vajrasana - 6 cycles
Krishnamacharya Surya Namaskara options
Krishnamacharya writes of staying for extended periods in each stage of what we now think of as a sun salutation or suryanamaskara. He writes of ten minutes or more below I take five long slow breaths in each.
Krishnamacharya shifts his kumbhaka around, generally, if the head is up it's antar kumbhaka, after the inhalation, if the head is down then it's bhya kumbhaka, after exhalation. generally there is no kumbhaka in twists.
Krishnamacharya shifts his kumbhaka around, generally, if the head is up it's antar kumbhaka, after the inhalation, if the head is down then it's bhya kumbhaka, after exhalation. generally there is no kumbhaka in twists.
Uttanasana B - AK5s
Chaturanga Dandasana - BK 3s
Urdhva Mukha Shvanasana - AK 5s
Adho Mukha Shvanasana BK-10s
Parivritta Trikonasana - 3
Utthita Parshvakonasana - 3
Parivritta Parshvakonasana - 3
Prasarita Padottanasana A. - 5
Parshvottanasana - 5 AK 5s
Utthita Hasta Padangushtasana plus standing marichi variation - 1 full breath in each stage
(I spent longer in standing postures this morning, usually I would split these up over two days)
Dandasana - 10 - AK 5s (scanning through vital points on inhalation hrdaya on exhalation)
Paschimattanasana - 15 - BK 5-10s (scanning through vital points on inhalation nasagra on exhalation)
Purvatanasana - 3
mahamudra -10 each side - BK 5-10s
Slower breathing, 10 second inhalations, 10 second exhalations
Janu Shirshasana A. - 1 each side
Marichyasana A C - one full breath in each variation and on each side
Tiriangmukhaikapada Paschimattanasana - 3
Bharadvajasana - 6 each side - AK 5s
Maha bandha - 6 each side- BK-5s
Ardha Matsyendrasana - 3 each side
Baddha Konasana - 10 each vinyasa - AK 5s for B (sitting up)
Padmasana with variations - 10 in total
Uth Pluthi - 5
shoulderstand prep ( 3 vinyasas) 3x each variation
Sarvangasana - 12 (legs relaxed )
viparita karani (sirsasana as mudra no variations) - 12
Sarvangasana with assorted variations - 5 mins ( see THIS post )
Shirshasana with assorted variations - 5 mins (see THIS post) - No intentional kumbhaka but I tend to try and lengthen the inhalation and exhalation as long as possible, between 30-45 second breath, gets slower as it goes on.
Baddha Padmasana - 10
Paranayama - basti - 30 and nadi sodhana -pratiloma ujjayi- with japa ( mentally reciting pranayama mantra 20s) - 6 cycles
Pratyahara 3 mins
trataka - 10 mins
savasana 5 mins
*******
but it perhaps give an impression of how slower breathing, longer stays, less asana might be approached.
Middle group practice
The practice from this morning that I outlined above was based on the Primary group asana, tomorrow I will most likely base my practice on the middle group, a similar approach to standing as above with perhaps some time spent on some tadasana backbending preparation variations from vinyasa Krama.
More time in Utthita Hasta Padangushtasana perhaps, in preparation for pasasana.
Tiriangmukhaikapada Paschimattanasana and krounchasana
I usually switch to the Vinyasa krama Bow sequence leading up to ustrasana, laugh vajrasana and kapotasana. The Bow sequence follows quite closely the layout of Ashtanga 2nd but with some extra vinyasas.
below kapotasana.
and in the leg behind head postures
I've started to leave out dwi pada sirsasana altogether and just practice a longer stay in yoga nidra
****
On the third day I would tend to switch back to primary group asana and explore some of the asana I missed from the regular Ashtanga sequence this morning and on the fourth day, asana missed from tomorrows Middle group.
******
We can practice less postures, below supposedly an example of Krishnamacharya's own personal practice from Krishnamacharya's 3rd son, TV Sribhashyam's book Emergence of Yoga.



10 comments:
I'm with you on this. In a led class I ignore the 'count' in a pose - I breathe at what feels like the right pace for me. I don't believe the count is suppose to equate exactly to the breath in any case. There are so many videos of Guruji leading a group and the count of 1..5 sometimes taking an age to start or being interrupted in the middle whilst he adjusts someone. No one seriously believes that you should be holding your breath whilst he does that. I used to try to breathe as fast as teachers counted and found I was hyperventilating.
For one's own practice I think the only thing that is important is to set the intention at the start of the session and then to try to stick to that intention. If you intend to practice five poses with slow breathing and retentions followed by 20 mins meditation then that is what you do. If you intend to get through full primary series in 60 mins then that is what you do. There are days when either one is the right practice for me - it's trusting myself to know which is right on a given day that is tricky.
Hello,
you mentioned that generally there is no kumbhaka in twists would it be possible to outline which asans I could do kumbhaka in the primary series of ashtanga?
thank you
Yes, all those without a twist, if the head is up the kumbhaka is after the inhalation if down then it's after the exhalation. The kumbhaka is short, settle for two seconds at first then increase it gradually to five. Try it in just a few asana each practice at first then explore it in other postures, integrating it throughout your practice gradually.
I hope i am not sending this twice? I am not sure that my first one got through. so, >
Thank you and will do. Your blog on vinyasa krama yoga and slow ashtanga is amazing! I have been practicing ashtanga for awhile now and its the first time I heard "kumbhaka" was here on your blog. I have since purchased the complete book of vinyasa yoga and I am reading yoga makaranda and I'm blown away with the approaches and info. I am sorry to say but what is being taught now as "ashtanga yoga" in the west and I can't speak for india, but from what i can tell it is probably not how krishnamacharya intended it to be practiced, not what we're seeing in shalas in the west? I mean could be wrong but it seems to be the case. I just wish I could find someone in my area who follows more the vinyasa krama yoga path...
I'm not sure i would have come to or stuck with the practice if i had started with 'slow ashtanga', maybe regular Ashtanga suited me in the beginning... at some point we take ownership of our practice and decide for ourselves how we want to approach it, Krishnamacharya's own writings can be an inspiration in this. Some shala's can be more supportive of this than others of course
actually you raise a very good point. to be honest initially I was attracted to ashtanga because it was faster flowing and offered a good intense practice with ujjayi breathing during practice, which we were told meant that our bodies we being detoxed through the flow and ujjayi breathing. I like to call it "stoking the furnace" e.g. chakra in this area, chinese call it dantian, I also practice qi gong. :) I came from a martial arts background so ashtanga was a good fit for me, our shala offered hatha yoga as well, but I rarely attended them! ;) but your point that eventually we take ownership of our practice and decide how to approach it or what works for me vs another person. its similar in martial arts when you rech a certain level of practice one the master will take a different approach on what he will teach one student vs another, and perhaps krishnamacharya would have done the same with different students with different bodies, etc...
Grim, your space is so lovely. That mountain view!! And wow, I am totally into that HEATER! I feel like you might have spoken about it before, I'm searching your archives, I must have one. No more would I have the "it's too cold" excuse. And what's up with this broken computer? Do you want me to fed ex you a harddrive? I'll totally do it. I miss your posts--but I can see how you've got the practice going on there, and the rocking rural Japanese pad, and who needs to write posts? :) Are you still teaching English, you must have had to leave your old job...? I'm probably just being nosy, sorry. Anyway, wishing you the best, still checking in, hoping to see something new in your corner of the internet.
Hi Maya, lovely to hear from you. It is a nice space, getting used to practice on tatami. I miss the shoji screens a little from the old place and the nice wood but it's warmer here and YES, such a view, the camera really doesn't do it justice.
I love the heater, was searching for a post where i featured it but can't find one. This post links to the old halogen heater, this is the same thing but round like the sun : )
http://grimmly2007.blogspot.jp/2012/12/new-halogen-heater-baddha-padmasana-on.html
Thank you for the hard drive offer, I've just been lazy, bit of a pain changing out an HD on a mac but not a problem to get one here.
Yes, still teaching English and in Osaka, so a long commute but I get to read and work on my Japanese.
Will try and post something soon, an end of year post at least and include lots of photos.
PS And you Maya, has you hard drive gone too, still the Zombocalypse over at your place ( great fun post btw).
have just added a new picture of the practice space pre practice this morning, shows up the new heater and the moon light nicely.
I know, I haven't posted, bad lady! Too bad I don't have a hard drive to blame it on. I've just misplaced my blogging mojo, I guess. Maybe it will come back. I did just post something new, a tiny thing--when one doesn't post for a while, a new thing becomes a bigger deal...which makes it harder to post, haha.
Love the practice space pic, I want one of those heaters! I found one on amazon, just haven't ordered it yet.
I forgot about the great train system in Japan, that you could live in the country and work in the city. Did you ever try WaniKani for learning kanji? It's very good, best I ran across, very organized and disciplined.
Looking forward to the promised post with photos. Merry Christmas, Grim! Best to you and yours.
Post a Comment
Note: only a member of this blog may post a comment.